A Primer in Mining Equity Investment

In the past paper, we talked about the vast performance disparity among metals, and offered our take on which metals to buy (Gold, Zinc) and which to avoid (Copper) going forward.

Not all metals are created equal - metals review

In this paper, we will provide the rationale behind mining equity investment, how to choose between metals futures or metals miners, and conclude with which mining sectors to buy and which to avoid.

Rationale behind mining equity investment:

The key to investing in mining equity is leverage. Suppose a copper miner's break-even point is 70 cents a pound. The company wouldn't have been worth much when copper was 70 cents as it couldn't turn a profit.

At a $1.00 copper price, however, the company will make 30 cents per pound of copper produced. And at $4.00 copper, its earnings will go up eleven times over to $3.30 cash earnings per pound.

Mining vs direct commodity investment

So the theory is that if copper prices go up 4-fold, copper mining stocks would go up 11-fold. In fact, this is pretty much what has happened since 2002. As copper went from 70 cents to $4.00, giant copper miners such as BHP went from $8 to $90.

BHP (BHP)

If BHP's case were universal to miners, would all investors jump on the mining bandwagon to take advantage of booming commodity prices?

Only if the case is so clear cut; indeed, if we look at Oil and Gold mining equities, a different picture emerges.

Crude went from $22/barrel post-Iraq War to now over $130/barrel, yet Exxon Mobil has merely doubled from $40 to $80.

Exxon Mobil (XOM):

Gold went from $250/oz in 2001 to $970/oz today, yet Barrick, world's largest gold miner, has merely tripled from $15 to $45.

Barrick Gold (ABX):

So why have gold miners and oil companies underperformed relative to gold and oil respectively? We can only speculate:

1. Equities seldom trade at fair value: investing would be easy if all companies were to trade at fair value. The sentiment pendulum swings to from fear to greed.
2. Equity investors are different from commodities futures investors. Mining investors seek earnings, while commodity investors are speculating on future prices.
3. Gold mining companies have "optionality value", which means their resource of gold in the ground yet to be mined. Such a concept is foreign to many earnings-focused money managers.
4. Mining is a risky business: accidents, nationalization, appropriation, labor strikes, tectonic movements and cost overruns are common.
5. Rock or Jewel? Metals prices are volatile, and stock valuation is forward looking. What future metal price does an analyst use to forecast the future earnings of a miner?
6. Mining is a burning stick: Miners need to constantly develop and acquire new reserves and properties. It is a costly and lengthy process to develop new deposits, which makes a valuation so much tougher to assign.

The point here is that the success of BHP, while not unique, is not the standard throughout the entire mining universe.

Junior Mining Sector in the dog house

If one looks for the speculative extreme in mining equities, the junior mining sector, a dire case could be made against investing in mining. The sector has utterly failed to live up to the expectations of investors. Junior resource equities are supposed to provide greater leverage than major mining producers. However, the nature of the business requires a constant injection of capital to discover and develop deposits before the eventual handsome operating cashflow is realized. This model is vulnerable to sudden and occasional credit/liquidity crunches like the one we're experiencing now.

The Toronto Stock Exchange Ventures Index, which is a proxy to junior stocks, merely doubled from the bottom of 1,000 to trade at 2,300.

Cash is king in uncertain times, and we like cash in gold.

We live in uncertain times. GSE's (Freddie Mac (FRE) and Fannie Mae (FNM)) are on life support with the Federal Reserve Bank of New York. All together, GSE's back $5 trillion US of low yield (5%-7%) assets. You have to wonder what the global asset managers holding those debts are going to do.

Real estate is cooling off worldwide now, from Singapore and Thailand to Vancouver. I am not seeing, nor do I think that housing will crash, though. The Asians are running in a mad panic over inflation and yet we have interest rates at 2-3% from Hong Kong to Singapore, Thailand to Japan, Korea to Taiwan. On top of that, we have global equity indices rotting with most down by double-digit percentages, with some, such as Vietnam's down some 70% this year. The point is there's nothing stronger to invest in at the moment than gold. We are now seeing a nice gold run as interest rates begin to trend up.

Conclusion:

This four-page paper is no means exhaustive, I hope however it served as a high-level overview on mining. The Barrick and junior resource camp may be glad to know 10-bagger success does happen to miners, as BHP demonstrated. The BHP camp might take caution in that mining isn't all risk-free glorious business.

We didn't have the foresight to put all our money in BHP, and instead we focused on juniors exploring for gold in exotic locations such as Africa. Being a Feng Shui student, I learn that every dog has its day, and perhaps finally it's time for the past dogs of Barrick and other gold miners to shine?

Comments

[Jake2]

I was left with a: "So what?" For example: "So why have gold miners and oil companies underperformed relative to gold and oil respectively? We can only speculate." Can't hang my hat on that, can I? I think you need to drill down a bit: more, harder numbers, more incisive analysis and then a stronger conclusion.
"10-bagger success does happen to miners . . . " sounds like wishful thinking to me.

[sandspider]

Being a hard core gold bug and silver bug, my take is the same as Jake2. Besides having physical possession of the stuff, I like the miners too. Safer then the ETF's in my opinion once the left takes total control of the government. We have yet to see the total tax and spend. Ex-pats including those of us in the combat zones are now being taxed on everything. Speaker of the house wants to tax all savings and IRA' and 401Ks etc etc. To make everyone equal she says. And Osama wants to create a tax to put a few billion into Africa and then of course take care of the descendents of the slaves forever, sooo to make a long winded story short, they be getting around to the gold and silver ETF's in nothing short. Horders will be criminals etc etc. So the mining stocks is where to be if you are holding anything public. But back to Jake2's comments, there is no meat here for me to sink my teeth into. What about the intermediates? What juniors have the best batting averages? ABX is buying up energy sources and others are looking to do the same for the future. Could this have an impact on making some of the majors a BHP of the future? Lots of good stuff out there just need something to hang my hat on.

[rhj123]

The odds of ever hitting a "ten bagger" are beyond belief! Years ago I entered into the mining stocks, mostly in the dollar types. Overall, I never made money, but did learn that those companies live on investor money. My two or three that became winners don't begin to offset the dozens of pure losers. Most stories of great management simply means they are good at dredging up more investors and then living on that income.

[vaduz]

i think the fate and performance of the stocks of big and middle gold/silver mining co could be much better, if these co would look at the investors as partners and not only as cash cows. it is for me never explained well, why there are not dividends of some magnitude paid in times of good earnings

[Clavis]

What a cynical lot, the juniors are going to make us all rich, do your homework, a selection of well managed mines; perhaps one or two adjacent to the 'big boy' spreads; with not too long a lead in and whoopee, bathing in champagne and eating caviar.